Grade: B+ (Solid entry, uneven but charming)
One of the MCU’s best scores. Doyle weaves regal, mournful themes for Asgard and a swaggering, heroic motif for Thor. It gives the film a classical, almost romantic-epic feel that later Thor movies abandoned for synth-pop. What Doesn’t Work 1. The Earth Scenes Are Clunky The New Mexico setting feels cheap compared to Asgard’s golden spires. The small-town romance between Thor and Jane Foster (Natalie Portman) lacks chemistry—Portman looks bored, and the script gives her nothing but “plucky scientist” clichés. The supporting Earthlings (Darcy, Selvig) are comic relief that lands about 60% of the time. Grade: B+ (Solid entry, uneven but charming) One
The first 30 minutes in Asgard are dense and exciting. The middle 45 minutes on Earth drag as Thor learns to be nice. Then the final battle in the Bifrost feels rushed and small-scale. The film never quite balances cosmic stakes with small-town shenanigans. What Doesn’t Work 1
